Chris Moneymaker: No, the wrong guy didn’t win the WSOP Colossus

Smith was down to just four big blinds in four-handed play.
Chris Moneymaker
Chris Moneymaker
Posted on: June 23, 2026 12:51 PDT

Every now and then, poker gets itself worked up like a possum in a trash can, and the whole internet starts yelling before anybody has finished reading the rules or the room.

That’s pretty much what happened after Justin Smith won the WSOP Colossus for $550,000 and a bracelet. The headline version sounded spicy enough: Did the wrong person win? Was there a mistake? Did somebody award half a million dollars and poker immortality to a man who should’ve been standing in the payout line with everybody else?

The internet found itself a nothing burger

Well…no.

What we had here was a classic Las Vegas nothing burger.